February 19, 2017
Actress Priya Prakash Varrier, who stole the heart of the
nation with her cute antics in a song of an upcoming Malyalam movie, on Monday
moved the Supreme Court seeking quashing of the FIRs against her and the
director of the film for hurting religious sentiments of Muslims.
The
actress, film director Omar Lulu and others sought an ex-parte stay on the FIR
and police complaints, and also appropriate orders restraining other states from
registering such FIRs.
Some Muslim activists had lodged an FIR against
the team of "Oru Adaar Love" in Hyderabad under Section 295A (hurting religious
sentiments) of the Indian Penal Code on February 14.
A group in
Maharashtra's Aurangabad also filed a police complaint against Varrier and Lulu
on the same grounds.
On Monday, Varrier's counsel Pallavi Pratap told the
apex court that the criminal complaints instituted by "various fringe groups"
are based on a "distorted and incorrect interpretation of the song".
"The
claims that it hurts the religious sentiments of the Muslim community are
without any basis," it said.
Stressing that an amount of Rs 1.5 crore has
been spent on the movie, the plea said "such flimsy and baseless complaints and
FIRs cause nothing but hindrance in freedom of speech".
The contentious
scene where Varrier winks at a boy features the Mappila lyrics -- a traditional
Muslim song from the Malabar region of Kerala -- that celebrate the love between
Prophet Mohammed and his first wife Khadija.
The complainants have
primarily objected to the use of Mappila as background music in the flirting
scene.
However, the petition said it was "hard to fathom" that a song
which has been in existence "for the past 40 years... was cherished by the
Muslim community in Kerala is now being treated as an insult... it cannot
suddenly offend the religious sentiment of the Muslim community".
The
plea said that the fringe elements have "misunderstood" the lyrics of the song.
"Filing of criminal complaints and registration of FIRs by the police in
multiple states on the basis of complaints by fringe elements... has adversely
affected the petitioners' right to life, liberty and freedom of expression.
"...the legality of the content of the film and the certification on the
same can only be dealt with under law by the Central Board of Film Certification
(CBFC)," it said.
Citing the apex court's order on November 16, 2017 that
a film or a drama or a novel or a book is a creation of art, the plea said these
complaints were contrary to the order.
The Supreme Court has observed
earlier that an artist has freedom to express himself and a thought-provoking
film "should never mean that it has to be didactic or in any way puritanical".